By Mike Zummo
It’s been a long week for all involved, even for those who got to the Section 9 Class AA championship game cleanly.
The second-seeded Newburgh Free Academy Goldbacks had the unenviable task of preparing without being exactly sure who they’d be playing.
The defense was strong, but the offense struggled in a 16-6 loss to the fourth-seeded Vikings in the Section 9 Class AA championship game at Monroe-Woodbury High School in Central Valley.
The Goldbacks initially expected a rematch against the top-seeded Middletown Middies, to whom they fell, 33-22, on Oct. 16.
However, the Middies, who blew out the Vikings, 48-15, in the Nov. 6 semifinal were discovered to have played an ineligible player during that victory causing them to forfeit the game and the Vikings were awarded a 21-0 victory.
According to multiple reports, the ineligible player was discovered while the Newburgh coaching staff was reviewing film of Middletown’s semifinal win over Valley Central and contacted the VC staff to inquire about the unfamiliar player. That led to VC contacting the Section 9 governing body which, in turn, led to the disqualification and forfeiture. It also led to a very public backlash against both Newburgh and Valley Central, and public appeals by numerous elected officials, including State Senator James Skoufis, to overturn the ruling and allow the Middies to play.
“As has been publicly acknowledged, the Middletown School District’s team, which has been disqualified for a rules violation, admitted to an administrative error regarding the requirements of the eligibility rules and has filed court papers seeking a temporary restraining order against our school district and our designated opponent for this Saturday’s Sectional Playoff Game, Valley Central,” said Dr. Jackielyn Manning Campbell, Newburgh’s Superintendent of Schools. “While we understand Middletown’s desire to protect its athletes from adult mistakes, it is deeply disappointing that our own student-athletes and coaches are now being unfairly criticized and scapegoated in the aftermath.”
Manning Campbell called the criticism “a textbook example of deflection.”
The Middies appealed the decision to both Section 9 and the New York Public High School Athletic Association but were denied both times. They took their case to the New York State Supreme Court on Friday but withdrew their petition before the judge could make a ruling.
During the appeals process, the Goldbacks were forced to prepare to face two different teams and weren’t certain of their opponent until Friday afternoon, less than 24 hours before kickoff.
After a scoreless first quarter, special teams got the Vikings on the board. Elijah Strother returned a punt to the Newburgh 20-yard line. Two plays later, Andrew Waite, the game’s offensive MVP connected with Jude Revella for an 18-yard touchdown to put the Vikings up 6-0 with 7:59 left in the third
quarter.
Then on their next possession, he connected with Triston Wright for a 17-yard touchdown pass to give the Vikings a 13-0 lead at halftime.
The Goldbacks, meanwhile didn’t get on the board until the fourth quarter when Justin Lassic scored on a 10-yard touchdown to cut the Vikings’ lead to 13-6 with 7:19 left in the game.
However, the Vikings followed with about a six-minute drive to the Newburgh 5-yard line. The Goldbacks gave up two big plays, the first a 20-yard pass from Waite to Triston Wright and another a 20-yard pass from Waite to Jude Revella to give the Vikings first-and-goal at the Newburgh 8.
That caused the Goldbacks to burn all three timeouts and Danny Joyce put the game out of reach with a 22-yard field goal.
The Vikings will travel to Colonie High School on Saturday to face the Section 2 champion. The Goldbacks finished the season, 8-3.