Newburgh Council seeks higher pay, equal salaries

Posted 11/18/26

Newburgh City Council members could receive salary increases of up to 41 percent under a proposal that would also eliminate pay differences among council members, drawing questions from residents …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Newburgh Council seeks higher pay, equal salaries

Posted

Newburgh City Council members could receive salary increases of up to 41 percent under a proposal that would also eliminate pay differences among council members, drawing questions from residents about the timing of the raises and whether elected officials should determine their own compensation.

The proposed changes would raise annual salaries for the city’s four ward representatives, Giselle Martinez (Ward 1), Ramona Monteverde (Ward 2), Tamika Stewart (Ward 3) and Ronald Zorrilla (Ward 4) from $17,000 to $24,000, a 41.2 percent increase. The two at-large council members, Robert McLymore, Sr. and Omari Shakur, would receive $24,000, up from $20,000, while Mayor Torrance Harvey’s salary would rise from $22,500 to $27,000. Both increases would amount to 20 percent.

The changes, which require an amendment to the City Charter, were the subject of a public hearing Nov. 9. Council members say the increases reflect the demands of their positions and an effort to bring compensation in line with other municipalities. However, residents questioned the financial justification and the process for approving the raises.

“Where does this fit in the overall financial priority of the city?” Dennis Grant, a Ward 1 resident, asked during the hearing. “As residents face rising costs with everyday expenses, concerning the Charter Review Commission, is this good timing? Is this council only the boss when it’s time to vote for your raises?”
Mayor Harvey defended the proposed increases, pointing to the work council members perform beyond their regular meetings and to salaries in neighboring municipalities. Harvey said council members spend time advocating for state and federal funding, attending conferences and building relationships with government officials to help secure investments for the city.

“We have to be in sight, in mind and if we’re out of sight, we’re out of mind,” Harvey said. “We don’t get that $10 million that just came for the South Interceptor or we don’t get those grants that have come down millions of dollars or half a billion dollars worth of public and private investment because we have to lobby and make sure when Newburgh’s applications come into those state government tables and federal government applications for grants that they get awarded through lobbying.”

The mayor also said that the Town of Newburgh council members earn approximately $44,000 to $46,000 annually, roughly twice his current salary.

In neighboring Beacon, the mayor currently makes $30,000 while council members make $11,000, according to the city charter. In Middletown, the mayor’s salary is $125,000, while aldermen earn $20,000 and the Common Council president earns $30,000, according to Local Law 4, which passed in 2025.

Councilmember Ramona Monteverde said the council had compared its compensation with other municipalities several years ago and found that Newburgh’s salaries were among the lowest. She said council members had subsequently agreed to pursue smaller, periodic increases rather than a substantial raise all at once.

Councilmember Giselle Martinez added that previous public comments had influenced the council’s approach, with some residents expressing support for the gradual increases rather than larger adjustments all at once.

Martinez also said the proposal would also address the pay disparity between ward and at-large representatives, who she argued carry similar responsibilities despite representing different constituencies.

“We all still have one vote and we all still do the same level of work,” Martinez said.

But the proposal drew objections during the Nov. 9 hearing, particularly over the council’s authority to approve its own compensation.

Pastor Rosemarie Lawal of Ward 1, who was appointed to the Charter Review Commission, questioned why the city was moving to amend the charter to increase council salaries just as a newly established Charter Review Commission was preparing to begin examining the document.

“This is not whether or not you deserve the money or the economy is calling for a raise,” Lawal said, arguing that the process raised questions about transparency and accountability.

She also questioned why council members could vote on their own salary increases when other city employees must go through established processes to obtain raises.

Harvey said that legislative bodies at the state and federal levels also vote on their own compensation, including members of Congress and the New York State Legislature.

He pointed to the council’s earlier decision to pursue gradual salary increases, saying the approach reflected feedback from residents during previous public hearings.

Not everyone who spoke at the hearing believed the proposed increases went far enough.

Michael LeBron, a Grand Street resident, said he opposed the proposal because the salaries remained too low for positions he considers full-time work. He suggested paying council members at least $85,000 annually and the mayor at least $135,000.

“You need a full-time salary for a full-time job,” LeBron said.

Monteverde and Martinez described their council responsibilities as extending well beyond regular meetings, with evenings and weekends often devoted to community events, constituent concerns and other city business.

Monteverde, who retired last year, said council members also handle their own research, correspondence and other responsibilities without extensive administrative support. She recalled attending three meetings in one week, with another community event scheduled for the following Sunday.

Martinez, who also works a full-time job, said she frequently gives up lunch breaks to meet with residents and spends much of her time outside work on council matters.

“My free time isn’t really free time; it’s all council work,” Martinez said.

Although the position is officially part time, Martinez described the responsibilities as closer to full-time work.

“I do believe that people deserve to get paid for the labor that they’re doing,” she said.