By Niko Balkaran
A newly formed commission tasked with examining the City of Newburgh’s governing document has begun laying the groundwork for a review that could reshape how local government operates, with members seeking funding and planning ways to involve residents in the process.
During its first two meetings on Nov. 12 and 16, the City of Newburgh Charter Review Commission voted to request up to $130,000 in funding, with $40,000 for the remainder of 2026 and $90,000 for 2027 to help support its work, including outside legal assistance and community outreach.
Established by the City Council in May, the commission is responsible for reviewing the City Charter, created in 1865, which defines the powers and responsibilities of city officials and establishes how municipal government operates. Members can recommend rewriting the charter, changing individual provisions or leaving it unchanged.
“Our call is to review this charter, go through it, read it, comprehend it, understand it,” Commission Chair Enine Williams said during the inaugural meeting.
The commission elected Williams, a Ward 4 resident, as chair; Shelby Aho, a Ward 2 resident, as vice chair; and Jules Ridgeway, also of Ward 4, as secretary.
The other regular members are Dr. Debra R. Lamb, Cassie Sklarz and Rosemarie Lawal of Ward 1; Steven Ciancanelli and Peter Frase of Ward 2; and Gaylord Geter of Ward 3.
Seven alternate members were also appointed: Mark C. Carnes, L. Simone Washington, Carla Johnson and Kamar Everett of Ward 1; Keesha Gaskins-Nathan of Ward 2; Jo Epstein of Ward 3; and Jorge Ortiz III of Ward 4.
Williams emphasized that commissioners should first study Newburgh’s existing charter, which was last reviewed in 2011 before deciding whether changes are necessary.
The commission also discussed how long the review could take and whether proposed changes could be ready for voters by next year’s election. Members acknowledged that they would have to consider legal requirements and election deadlines before establishing their timeline.
“We have to be very strategic. We’re going to have to be very time-conscious, and we’re going to have to be very diligent in order to get this done,” Williams said.
Public participation emerged as a priority during the first meeting, with commissioners discussing ways to gather input beyond the traditional public comment period.
Neighborhood roundtables and written submissions also came up as ideas for the public to interact with the commission to share their thoughts and opinions. Members also raised the possibility of holding discussions in different parts of Newburgh to reach residents who might not otherwise be able to attend commission meetings.
In an interview following the inaugural meeting, Aho expressed optimism about the commission’s potential to involve more residents in local decision-making.
“I think I’m hopeful for what we can help with, and I’m ready to see more Newburgh residents in these spaces,” she said.
Aho said she was interested in seeing greater collaboration between residents and local government as the commission carries out its review.
At the Nov. 16 meeting, commissioners took steps toward establishing a framework for that outreach, including approving a Communications Committee, with Lawal and Ciancanelli as co-chairs, to share information about meetings, public comment opportunities and the progress of the review.
Members discussed social media updates, printed materials, multilingual outreach and summaries of commission meetings written in language residents can easily understand.
Commissioners also voted to allow residents four minutes each to speak on agenda items during regular public comment periods, settling on a compromise after members debated whether speakers should receive three or five minutes.
While public comments at meetings will be limited to agenda items, commissioners also discussed organizing community roundtables to gather broader resident input on the charter and how city government operates.
The commission’s outreach efforts could receive additional assistance from Assemblymember Jonathan Jacobson, who, according to Ridgeway, has committed funding for citywide mailings to inform residents about the charter review process.
Ridgeway told commissioners Nov. 16 that the mailings could reach more than 12,000 registered voters and provide information about upcoming meetings and community discussions. She added that Jacobson had not specified a limit on the number of mailings he would support.
The announcement came as members discussed distributing flyers and other materials throughout the city’s four wards, including the possibility of employing young residents to assist with outreach.
Ridgeway was also tasked with preparing the commission’s funding requests for Williams and Aho to review before submitting them to the city manager.
Commissioners also established a finance and planning group to help organize anticipated expenses and authorized their leadership to seek written proposals from law and consulting firms that could assist with the charter review.
The commission also unanimously elected Gaskins-Nathan as sergeant-at-arms, filling an additional position discussed during the inaugural meeting. The commission designated it as a non-officer role that does not have to be held by a regular member.
The next commission meeting is planned for Monday, Nov. 30, at 7 p.m. at the Activity Center.