By Mark Reynolds
Last fall, after a 6-month moratorium, the Plattekill Town Board voted unanimously to ban large-scale Battery Energy Storage Systems [BESS] in town, citing the potential of fires, the impacts to human health, safety and the environment due to the release of toxic chemicals and the difficulty of completely putting them out. The law, however, allows residents to have a modest battery system at their homes.
On December 30, Ulster County Legislator and Minority Leader Republican Kevin Roberts [Dist-12 Plattekill] issued a press release stating that the Republican Caucus reaffirms their opposition to these facilities, “citing serious and unresolved public safety risks highlighted by recent events in the Hudson Valley.”
Roberts elaborated on ‘recent events:’
“On December 19, 2025, a lithium-ion battery storage facility in Warwick, NY caught fire, prompting emergency air monitoring that detected hydrogen cyanide, a highly toxic gas, in surrounding air samples. While officials indicated that levels were below federal exposure limits, the presence of such a dangerous chemical during an active fire underscores the inherent risks associated with large-scale battery storage.” Ronk further stated that, “when a facility fire produces toxic gases like hydrogen cyanide, even at so-called “acceptable” levels, it demonstrates how serious the consequences can be when these systems fail.”
The Warwick fire occurred at the Convergent Energy Battery Storage Facility at 28 Church Street. The fire call came in at 10:15p.m., which immediately brought local police, fire departments and the Orange County Hazardous Materials Unit to the scene. It was determined that the fire started after water infiltrated the battery system, the same cause cited for another fire in 2023. After that fire Convergent Energy promised the community that such an incident would never happen again.
Roberts noted that the Warwick incident is what led Plattekill officials to impose a moratorium and later a ban, on new battery storage facilities.
“Lithium-ion battery fires are widely recognized as difficult to extinguish, capable of reigniting, and known to emit toxic and flammable gases during thermal runaway events,” the press release stated.
Deputy Minority Leader Republican Craig Lopez [Dist-14 Towns of Shawangunk, Wawarsing] emphasized that these repeated incidents show that the risks are no longer theoretical and that communities should not be treated as testing grounds for technology that has not yet demonstrated consistent, long-term safety.”
Republican Rich Walls [Dist-13 Town of Shawangunk] warned that, “placing large-scale battery storage facilities near homes and critical infrastructure presents significant and unresolved safety risks, particularly when emergency response capabilities are limited.”
The Ulster County Republican Caucus continues to call for a pause on all BESS approvals until, “comprehensive, independent safety reviews are completed, emergency response standards are clearly defined, and proven risk-mitigation measures are in place. Energy innovation must never come at the expense of public health, First-Responder safety, and the well-being of Ulster County residents.”
In a subsequent interview, Roberts said he made himself more aware of the hazards of these facilities when a presentation was made by Mission Clear Energy for a 300-watt Battery Energy Storage facility in Plattekill. The company has since pulled their project, however, one has recently been proposed in the Town of Hurley.
Roberts said Hurley’s representative, Democrat Eric Stewart [Dist 18 Towns of Hurley, Marbletown], joined the Republican resolution opposing these facilities.
Roberts described the outcome in the Legislature.
“Both times the Democrats on the Environmental Committee were against it and one failed on the floor,” he said, adding that the other side of the aisle believes these facilities are safe and should be a part of the Green Energy plan. Roberts disagreed, saying, “Ulster County should not be a testing ground for these poisonous facilities,” noting that the Warwick fire showed that hydrogen cyanide was released. “I don’t care at what levels, what levels will it be next time? It’s a poisonous gas, so much so that the French used in in WW I in chemical warfare.”
Roberts commended the Plattekill Town Board for banning these facilities, “and more towns in Ulster County should do it outright. We should take control of our future and not be dictated by a Green Energy plan that’s not going to work.”
Former Plattekill Supervisor Dean DePew led the board during discussions of Battery Storage facilities, recalling that the board began considering this issue in mid 2023 because they knew that energy companies were beginning to look more seriously at the Hudson Valley when looking to locate these types of facilities.
Coming into office, DePew established a committee that began looking at this issue, especially from an environmental perspective. They reviewed sites not only in New York but in other states where there have been fires at these facilities. They also discovered that many facilities took advantage of federal funding, with companies selling the storage project shortly after receiving the needed approvals from town planning boards.
DePew said during this entire process of banning these facilities in town, “We did our research, we did reach out to our attorneys, we vetted the law and checked every box we could to make sure that we did everything appropriately.”