By Mark Reynolds
A former vice president of the Marlboro Board of Education is urging the board to fill a vacant seat rather than leave it empty until May 2027.
James Mullen spoke during public comment at a recent board meeting. He said he has listened to every board meeting over the past four months and is invested in the school district.
“I respect the time and commitment each of you gives to our community, but I am dis-appointed in the decision to leave the vacancy in the Board of Education unfilled until May [2027],” Mullen said. “Our own board policy 1230 states that the district has the power and the duty to fill that vacancy. I understand that state law provides some dis-cretion in how vacancies are addressed, and I am not here to suggest that the board has definitively violated the law, but I do believe that language creates a responsibility to carefully consider the available options and explain the decision publicly.”
Mullen said the issue ties into the importance of transparency.
“A decision affecting our community representation deserves an open conversation,” he said. “Each of you was elected as one of seven board members, not one of six. Leaving the seat vacant increases each remaining member’s relative voting influence while giv-ing our community one fewer voice at the table. I am not suggesting that anyone is in-tentionally seeking more influence, but that is the practical result. With the budget sea-son approaching and the capital project beginning, I believe seven perspectives are es-pecially important. Operating with six also creates the possibility of 3-3 votes on criti-cal decisions.”
A tie vote means a measure fails.
Mullen acknowledged the financial impact of holding a special election but said an ap-pointment is another option, citing a decision by the commissioner of education. He suggested he could return to help with the budget and the capital project.
“But this is not about me, it’s about restoring full representation and ensuring that our community understands why a seat is being left empty,” he said. “I respectfully ask the board to reconsider its decision, publicly explain its reasoning and give serious consid-eration to filling this vacant seat.”
The vacancy stems from the board’s Oct. 15 meeting, when board member Michael Schreiber was approved as the district’s new director of school business and finance, leaving his board seat open.
Superintendent Michael Rydell said a number of candidates applied for the position, “and as we went through the process we recognized that something was missing here, something was missing there. Ultimately, that led to a conversation, which led to Michael [Schreiber] putting in for the position after he was asked multiple times.”
“We literally have a top candidate who is a resident and who went through the Marl-boro Central School District and cares so much about the community ... That’s who our next director of school business and finance is, pending approval from the remainder of the board,” Rydell said. “I want to say, Michael, I’m really excited, and [in] the few months you have been a board trustee, you’ve been an incredible asset. I’m just really excited about working with you, learning from you and all that you’re going to do on a full-time basis.”
The board voted unanimously to hire Schreiber. His probationary period runs from Nov. 9, 2026, through Nov. 9, 2030, at a prorated salary of $165,000.
Rydell said the trustee vacancy will be discussed at the board’s meeting Thursday, Nov. 19.
“I am very confident the Board of Education will have a thorough discussion and make a decision on the desired next steps in the process during the board discussion portion of the meeting,” he said.