Former Newburgh pastor sentenced to probation, weekend jail time

Posted 4/30/25

Former Newburgh pastor William Damroth was sentenced Tuesday in Orange County Court to five years of probation and 16 weekends in jail after pleading guilty in December to second-degree larceny.

…

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

Former Newburgh pastor sentenced to probation, weekend jail time

Posted

Former Newburgh pastor William Damroth was sentenced Tuesday in Orange County Court to five years of probation and 16 weekends in jail after pleading guilty in December to second-degree larceny.

Damroth, who once led St. Mother Teresa of Calcutta parish in the City of Newburgh, admitted to stealing $300,000 from the parish. He has since paid full restitution.

Under the sentence handed down by Judge Craig S. Brown, Damroth must report to the Orange County Jail by 5 p.m. each Friday and will be released each Sunday evening. Missing a weekend could result in a probation violation and resentencing.

Damroth is also required to complete 500 hours of community service, with at least 100 hours finished within one year. The work must be done through a nonprofit approved by the county’s probation department.

Originally reassigned in 2022 to Immaculate Conception Parish in Port Jervis, Damroth left St. Mother Teresa of Calcutta shortly before a financial audit by the Archdiocese of New York revealed discrepancies. He was formally charged in December 2023 and entered his guilty plea on Dec. 17, 2024.

Appearing in court Tuesday with supporters and his attorney, Joseph Gulino, Damroth spoke about his faith and the personal hardships he has faced in recent years, including the deaths of family members and deteriorating health. He said he struggled with the stress of overseeing the merged parishes of Sacred Heart and St. Francis of Assisi in Newburgh, and described the area surrounding the parish, including Benkard Avenue, as plagued by crime and drug use.

Judge Brown had previously insisted on some jail time as part of the sentencing. Gulino said he was satisfied with the court’s final decision.

“I think it’s a fair sentence,” Gulino said. “The 16 weekends allow for the continuation of his medical care without placing a burden on the jail.”

Damroth has been diagnosed with kidney failure, requires regular dialysis, and uses a catheter for treatment. He is currently being considered for a kidney transplant.

“We spent several appearances, spanning multiple adjournments, gathering medical documentation and proof to present to the court,” Gulino said. “We also took care of restitution, so this is a fair middle ground.”

Damroth will begin serving his weekend sentence this Friday.