Editorial

A smarter path forward

This September, schools across New York will open their doors under a new mandate: a bell-to-bell ban on student smartphones and personal devices. Governor Kathy Hochul’s initiative, developed …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in
Editorial

A smarter path forward

Posted

This September, schools across New York will open their doors under a new mandate: a bell-to-bell ban on student smartphones and personal devices. Governor Kathy Hochul’s initiative, developed in response to concerns voiced by teachers, parents and students, represents a decisive step toward reclaiming classrooms from the constant hum of digital distraction.

The law is straightforward—students may not use their phones during the school day. But its implications run much deeper. For too long, the addictive pull of smartphones has shaped student life, often to the detriment of focus, mental health and personal connection. With 95 percent of teenagers owning smartphones and receiving, on average, 250 notifications a day, the classroom has been competing with an endless stream of alerts, memes, and messages. No amount of discipline or teacher ingenuity can truly counter that flood.

This policy is not about punishment. It is about giving young people the freedom to learn without interruption, to socialize face-to-face, and to grow in ways unmediated by a screen. Research and school-based evidence are clear: when students are freed from their phones, engagement rises, attention sharpens and social connections strengthen. Classrooms become calmer, and teachers can do what they are trained to do—teach—without playing the role of device referee.

Governor Hochul captured the spirit of this shift when she said she wants “laughter in the hallways again” and “human voices in gym class.” Those are not nostalgic whims; they are essential elements of a healthy, thriving school community. Eye contact, conversation, collaboration—these are the cornerstones of education that smartphones have slowly eroded.

We recognize that this change will require adjustment for families, students and educators alike. Parents may worry about reaching their children during the day, and students may struggle at first without their familiar devices. But schools are already developing policies tailored to their communities, and parents with questions are encouraged to contact their district offices. The goal is not to isolate students from the world, but to restore balance and prioritize their well-being during school hours.

There will be resistance, as with any major cultural change. But years from now, we may look back on this moment as a turning point—a recognition that we cannot let technology dictate the pace and quality of our children’s education. By creating distraction-free schools, New York is offering its students the gift of presence, resilience and real human connection.

That is not just smart policy. It is smart parenting, smart teaching and, ultimately, a smarter future.